Case Study Health Insurance Platform Selection

A cloud contact center chosen to fit the CRM, for a $1B insurer

U.S. benefits and health insurance organization · Multi-channel contact center

CRM-Ready Integration requirement

Vendor-Blind Evaluation criteria set first

The Challenge

The CRM was chosen. The contact center platform behind it wasn't.

The organization had committed to a new CRM to improve the experience for agents and customers. That decision created the next one: which multi-channel cloud contact center platform would integrate with it. Nobody inside the company was free to run a vendor evaluation, and waiting for someone to become free would push the CRM timeline. The wrong pick would live in the operation for years.

No evaluation muscle in-house

No internal team dedicated to vendor evaluation, and no recent market knowledge to lean on.

A decision already constraining this one

The CRM was locked in. Every platform candidate had to prove it could integrate with it.

Competing selection criteria

Capabilities, cost, cultural fit, and long-term scalability all mattered, and stakeholders weighed them differently.

Our Approach

Define what matters first. Then make the vendors answer to it.

01

Strategic Alignment

Facilitated sessions with key stakeholders to settle priorities, must-have capabilities, and evaluation criteria before any vendor entered the room.

02

Custom RFP Development

Built a tailored RFP covering costs, capabilities, support, implementation requirements, and CRM integration. Every vendor answered the same questions in the same structure.

03

Decision Framework

Created a scoring matrix weighted by the attributes that mattered most to operations and long-term goals. Comparison stopped being a matter of opinion.

04

Financial & Technical Analysis

Documented recommendations backed by financial modeling and technical evaluation, so the decision could be defended line by line.

The Results

A selection the whole organization could stand behind.

8 Weeks

from kickoff to final vendor recommendation, with core team and extended stakeholders aligned on the choice

Selection process, kickoff to recommendation

01

Strategic
Alignment

02

RFP
Development

03

Decision
Framework

04

Financial & Technical
Analysis

05

Recommendation
Delivered

The full sequence, run once, in order. Criteria were locked before vendors were contacted, so no stage had to be repeated.

01

A vendor-ready RFP the organization owns

Evaluation process, market analysis, and a structured response framework, reusable the next time a platform decision comes up.

02

A 6-month implementation roadmap

Platform design, CRM integration planning, and phased deployment mapped out before contract signature. Selection connected directly to go-live.

03

A decision stakeholders agreed on

The scoring matrix turned competing priorities into a weighted comparison everyone had already signed off on. The recommendation landed without a second round of debate.

More Case Studies